Wednesday, May 6, 2009

Max Henneberg



Crew Member

Age: 43

Hometown: Hamburg

Occupation: Room steward

Location at time of fire: Passenger decks, portside dining salon

Survived



Max Henneberg, born in Hamburg in 1893, was a descendent of the House of Henneberg (itself a branch of the Babenbergs,) which existed from the 1100s through the 1500s. At its height, the House of Henneberg was quite powerful in the duchies of Thuringia and Franconia. Max Henneberg's branch of the family had moved north and settled in Hamburg in the 1800s. His mother died during childbirth, and his father remarried shortly thereafter, and then passed away himself about five years later.


Henneberg went to the naval academy in Hamburg, and graduated as a naval cadet at age 16. He joined the German Navy after graduation, and during WWI he was aboard a destroyer that was sunk during the Battle of Jutland. Henneberg survived for four hours in the icy waters of the North Sea before being rescued by a British ship, and he spent the rest of the war as a prisoner.

After the war, Max Henneberg and several of his friends worked as air mail pilots, flying mail all over Germany. However, the early airplanes were not particularly reliable, and Henneberg survived several crashes and forced landings before deciding that the life of a pilot wasn't for him. Through a friend of his family, Henneberg found work with the Hamburg-America steamship line. For 13 years, from 1922 through 1935, he sailed on various ocean liners, starting off as a dishwasher on his earliest trips, quickly becoming a steward, and then by 1929 rising to the level of Chief Steward. During these years he sailed around the globe several times.

On one of these voyages, Henneberg and three other members of the crew were playing a game of bridge. As the ship made its way through the Panama Canal, one of the men had to go on watch, so Henneberg invited one of the passengers, a young lady named Marta Balve, to join them and take over the empty spot in the game. Miss Balve was a practical nurse who specialized in the treatment of severe leg injuries. She worked with doctors in New York and Los Angeles, though she was from Germany. When she met Max Henneberg, Miss Balve was on her way back from Los Angeles to visit her home town of Düsseldorf. The two ended up dating for several years, although Marta spent most of her time living and working in the United States, and Henneberg was at sea a great deal of the time.

In late 1935, the Deutsche Zeppelin Reederei began advertising for stewards for their new transatlantic airship, the LZ-129 Hindenburg, which was scheduled to make its first flights in early 1936. Thousands of applicants, including Max Henneberg, turned out for less than half a dozen open steward positions on the DZR's new airship. Henneberg was ultimately one of those who were hired, and he made his first flight in early May of 1936, a couple of months after the Hindenburg was commissioned. He made all of the rest of the flights during that first year, as well as all of the flights at the beginning of 1937.


Max Henneberg (in white jacket at left) serves Prince Rangsit and Princess Valaya of Siam during the Hindenburg's flight over the opening ceremonies of the 1936 Olympics in Berlin, on August 1st, 1936. (photo courtesy of the Luftschiffbau Zeppelin GmBH Archive)




 

Max Henneberg (center, in doorway) in the small serving pantry in the Hindenburg's dining salon, circa 1936. Also visible in this photo are stewards Fritz Deeg (in pantry, to left of Henneberg) and Eugen Nunnenmacher (right).


Max Henneberg was, therefore on the Hindenburg's first North American flight of the 1937 season. As the ship came in to land at Lakehurst at the end of the flight on May 6th, Henneberg had just finished straightening up the new cabins on B-deck along with one of the other stewards, and then went upstairs to the lounge on the starboard side of the passenger decks. Since so many of the passengers were already gathered there to watch the landing, however, Henneberg walked over to the dining room on the port side of the passenger decks where there was more room at the observation windows. He found a spot near one of the forward-most windows, and was watching the landing operations on the ground from there when he looked aft towards the engines and suddenly noticed a fiery glow coming from back toward the stern of the ship.


Max Henneberg's location on the portside passenger deck at the time of the fire.



Henneberg heard a sharp detonation moments after this that, based on his experiences in World War I, he later likened to the sound of a heavy artillery piece being fired. The shock of the detonation and the subsequent tilting of the ship aft threw Henneberg headlong to the floor along with two passengers (probably Otto and Elsa Ernst) who had been sitting on a bench to his left, and as he tried to rise he was thrown down a second time. He pulled himself up once more and made his way to the forward window again. Climbing up on the windowsill, Henneberg lowered himself through the window and hung there, waiting for the ship to drop closer to the ground before he finally let go from a height of about 15-20 feet. Henneberg ran to safety, and then returned with others to rescue passengers still trapped inside the ship.


Max Henneberg (arrow) lowers himself through one of the forward-most observation windows on the port side of the passenger deck.



 

He hangs momentarily, waiting until the ground is a bit closer...



 

...then lets go and drops into the sand about 15-20 feet below.




He subsequently went over to the DZR office in one of the airplane hangars where the crew survivors were gathering. Radio announcer Herb Morrison, who was set up in the same airplane hangar cutting a recording of his description of the landing and then the fire, spoke off-microphone with Henneberg and later mentioned this in his recording:

And now ladies and gentlemen, I’ve just walked back here into the office after checking up with a member of the crew. It happened to be… Henneberg. Henneberg. He was a member of the crew, was wearing a white coat. I don’t know what he was, maybe one of the stewards. He looked like he was one of the stewards, and, uh, another man here, and what was, [to man off-mic] did you know the other man’s name? Did you… [man off-mic: “ Clemens?”] uh, did you know the… oh no, uh, yes I announced, uh, Mr. Clemens. All right, and there’s another man just walked up. [man off-mic: (unintelligible)] Mr. Henneberg too, I wanted to tell you, is uninjured and he walked in here with several bundles under his arm, now what, what, uh, the man had in his arms when he fell out of the, uh, dirigible I don’t know, but he has two paper bundles and there’s not a bit of scorching on either bundle. Now, how it happened (chuckles) I couldn’t begin to tell you, because, uh, he landed in… it’s fortunate that it was over where there’s deep sand, and when he jumped down out of the dirigible, out of the cabin, they lit into the sand, and they didn’t receive any broken bones, the ones who I have talked to.



Max Henneberg was not seriously injured at Lakehurst, having merely twisted his ankle slightly when he dropped to the ground. Marta Balve, who was living and working in New York at the time, had been on her way down to Lakehurst to see Henneberg during the brief stopover before the Hindenburg was to have sailed back to Germany later that evening. Henneberg ended up staying with Marta in New York until it was time for him to return to Germany.

He remained in the States long enough to testify before the US Commerce Department's Board of Inquiry on May 13th, exactly a week after the disaster. Henneberg was, in fact, the first of the crew survivors to testify, and spoke partly in English, and partly through an interpreter, Benjamin J. Schnitzer of Akron, Ohio. Henneberg then sailed for Germany on Saturday, May 15th, along with the surviving steward and kitchen staff, onboard the steamship
Europa. They docked in Bremerhaven a week later on May 22nd.




Two photos of a small cocktail ice hammer that Max Henneberg picked up from the Hindenburg's wreckage as a memento. The ice hammer was most likely found in the vicinity of the ship's smoking room/bar, but could also have come from the ship's galley. Note the etched DZR logo visible in the second photo.



With no more passenger airships to serve aboard, Henneberg made a few more ocean voyages, then later in 1937 he landed a job as Inhaber (proprietor) of Schümann's Austernkeller, an inn and oyster bar in Hamburg's Inner Sea district. Established in the summer of 1884 by August Wilhelm Daniel Schümann, the upscale restaurant consisted of eleven individual dining rooms – tiny intimate rooms for two guests, all the way up to large dining areas with seating for two dozen. The restaurant was quite popular with celebrities and national figures, and each room had its own unique design as well as its own dedicated waiter. Max Henneberg would continue to run the inn throughout World War II, and it would remain a fixture on the Jungfernstieg until it finally closed in late 2000.

In 1939, Max Henneberg and Marta Balve were married and moved into a house in Hamburg, not far from the inn. Their first daughter, Elisabeth, was born the following year. As the war intensified, Hamburg, a major port as well as an industrial center, became a prime target for Allied bombing raids. In 1942, the Henneberg house was heavily damaged during one of these raids, and the family moved to a farm house in Rellingen, which was about 20 miles northwest of Hamburg, where they lived for the rest of the war. Max Henneberg continued to make the journey into Hamburg every day, however, to run the inn.

Rellingen house The house in Rellingen – the Henneberg family occupied the house’s upper floors. (photo courtesy of Elisabeth Henneberg.)

After the war, British occupation forces set up headquarters in an old manor house across the road from where the Hennebergs were living. The British were pleased to learn that they had English-speaking Germans living so close to them, and a cordial relationship developed between the Hennebergs and the British commander. Max Henneberg wanted Marta and the girls (they now had three) to go to the United States as soon as possible, and arranged with the British commander to find passage for them. In early 1946, Marta Henneberg and her daughters sailed from Bremerhaven on a troop ship. After docking in New York, they went cross country to Los Angeles, where Marta's sister lived.


Max and Elisabeth Henneberg Max Henneberg with his eldest daughter, Elisabeth, in the mid-1940s. (photo courtesy of Elisabeth Henneberg.)


Max Henneberg was to follow as soon as could be arranged, and had plans to turn his lifelong talent at drawing and painting into a new career in architecture once he got to the United States. Unfortunately, this was not to be. He developed cancer and died in Hamburg in 1949.

Marta Henneberg eventually moved to San Francisco where she lived for many years until she passed away at the age of 93, leaving three daughters, nine grandchildren, and several great-grandchildren.


I'd like to express my gratitude to Elisabeth Henneberg, Max's daughter, who generously shared with me a great many biographical details about her father and mother, and also provided the photos of herself with her father and of their house in Rellingen, as well as the portrait photo for me to use at the beginning of this article – and the ice hammer that her father kept from the Hindenburg's wreckage. Without Elisabeth's help, this article on her father would have been quite brief and would have primarily focused on his experiences as a Hindenburg steward. It's my very great pleasure to have the opportunity to tell Max Henneberg's story in far more detail than has previously been published.


Major Hans-Hugo Witt


Passenger

Age: 36

Residence: Barth-in-Pommern, Germany

Occupation: Luftwaffe Major

Location at time of fire: Passenger decks, starboard observation lounge

Survived



Major Hans-Hugo Witt, born in Rostock in Mecklenburg, near the edge of the Baltic Sea, in about 1901. Witt was an officer in the Luftwaffe, and had been with the Luftwaffe since its inception in 1935, though he had been a pilot since 1925. In October of 1935, Witt had been named commander of Sturzkampfgeschwader 162, Group 1, a dive bomber squadron based out of Schwerin. However, in April of 1937, Witt's squadron was reassigned as Group IV of a training squadron, Lehrgeschwader Greifswald.

The following month, Witt was given an assignment, along with two other Luftwaffe officers, Colonel Fritz Erdmann and First Lieutenant Claus Hinkelbein, to make a transatlantic flight aboard the airship Hindenburg on its first North American flight of 1937. The three men were in fact military observers, traveling in civilian clothing, who were aboard the ship to learn about the cutting-edge long-range navigational and weather-forecasting techniques employed by the ship's command crew, as well as to observe the overall operation of the ship.

It has been alleged, primarily by author Michael M. Mooney in his 1972 book "The Hindenburg", that the three Luftwaffe officers were in fact aboard the last flight as security officers, charged with the task of identifying and stopping a potential saboteur. No credible evidence has ever surfaced to support this allegation, and all references to this claim seem to be based solely on the unsupported assertions that Mooney made in his book. As a point of fact, both German and American military observers had been aboard virtually every flight of the Hindenburg during its 1936 season, observing the operation and design of the ship. It was even common practice in 1936 for these military observers to travel in civilian clothes, as did Witt, Erdmann, and Hinkelbein on the first North American flight of the 1937 season.

Prior to the Hindenburg's flight, when Witt and the others were in Frankfurt waiting to board the ship, Witt noticed that the passenger baggage was being searched rather more thoroughly than he would have expected. Witt was talking with his brother and another man who was a Deutsche Zeppelin Reederei representative and he mentioned the baggage search. It didn't affect Witt himself because he had a military passport and was therefore exempt from having his baggage searched, but he was curious nonetheless. The DZR representative told him that an anonymous warning had been received about a possible sabotage threat, and that this was the reason for the increased diligence in searching the passengers' baggage.

This is probably the nugget of truth that Mooney used in order to concoct his tale about the three Luftwaffe men being aboard the ship to look for bombs. However, when Witt mentioned this exchange in his testimony to the US Commerce Department's Board of Inquiry following the disaster, he specifically said that he heard nothing more about the sabotage warning after that exchange with the DZR representative, and that he'd heard nothing about it before the day of departure. Witt's feeling seemed to be that had he not asked about the baggage search, the subject might not have come up at all. Coupled with the fact that there had reportedly been numerous sabotage threats to the Hindenburg throughout 1936, there is no reason to assume that Witt's having heard about a sabotage warning before the last flight was connected in any way with any secret in-flight security duty assigned to him, Hinkelbein or Erdmann.

During the flight, Witt and the other two Luftwaffe officers made frequent trips to the ship's control car to observe the navigators at their duties, and also were freely escorted throughout the rest of the ship, notably places such as the engine gondolas and the electrical center, as had been customary with military observers in 1936. It being the first time the three men had flown on a Zeppelin, it was all relatively new to them.

As the Hindenburg approached the landing field at Lakehurst at the end of the flight, Maj. Witt was in the starboard passenger lounge, standing with Col. Erdmann, Lt. Hinkelbein and fellow passenger George Hirschfeld watching the ground crew from one of the observation windows. The ship made a turn to starboard as it approached the mooring mast, obscuring Witt's view of the ground operations, and after watching the ship's bow lines drop, Witt decided to go across to the port side windows to get a better look.


Major Witt's location in the starboard lounge at the time of the fire.


Suddenly, Witt heard somebody cry out that the ship was on fire. At the same moment, he heard a dull detonation and felt the ship shake and begin to tilt aft. He lost his footing and slid along the floor, coming to rest along with a pile of chairs against the rear wall of the lounge, near the door to the hallway leading to the cabin area and the portside dining room. The door was closed and one of the American passengers tried unsuccessfully to pull the jammed door open.

By now Witt could see the glow of the fire through the ceiling above him, and he felt the floor leveling out again as the bow of the ship dropped. Witt climbed to his feet and ran to one of the observation windows, jumping from a height of approximately 20 feet. He remembered nothing from the moment he jumped until he realized that Lt. Hinkelbein and another man were untangling a length of burning cable from around Witt's neck and carrying him to safety. He had apparently been caught by collapsing wreckage once he landed, as were many of the passengers on the starboard side, and had Hinkelbein and the other man not found him when they did, Witt may well have not made it out alive.


Hans-Hugo Witt in an ambulance shortly after the fire.



Major Witt being transferred to Lenox Hill Hospital, May 7th, 1937


Witt was taken to nearby Paul Kimball hospital with burns to his face, head, and hands. He was moved the next day to Lenox Hill Hospital in New York where he recovered for several weeks after the fire. He testified to the Board of Inquiry from his hospital bed on May 28th. Shortly after this, with his health improving, Witt was taken on a day trip, along with injured Hindenburg engine mechanic Theodor Ritter, to visit the US Army academy at West Point.

Witt returned to Germany after recovering from his injuries, and in September of 1937 he transferred to the Luftwaffe General Staff in Berlin. He was then given command of flight group Jagdgeschwader 26 on December 14th, 1939, but was relieved at the end of the Battle of France on June 23rd, 1940, and spent the rest of the war in staff positions. After the war, Witt took on a job as a lead caster in a German battery factory, eventually taking a position as a salesman with the firm.

Hans-Hugo Witt passed away in 1976 at the age of 75.

Special thanks to Luftwaffe historian Don Caldwell, who was kind enough to provide me with details about Hans-Hugo Witt's wartime service, as well as his post-war life.


Jonny Dörflein



Crew Member

Age: 26

Hometown: Frankfurt

Occupation: Engine mechanic

Location at time of fire: Engine gondola #3, starboard forward

Survived



Jonny Dörflein was one of the Hindenburg's engine mechanics. Born in Hamburg on August 2, 1910, he had flown with the Hindenburg as a trainee in early 1936, and was made a permanent member of the ship's staff of mechanics in August of 1936. He was aboard the Hindenburg's first North American flight of 1937, standing watch in engine gondola number 3, forward on the starboard side, along with fellow mechanic Willy Scheef, chief mechanic German Zettel, and mechanic trainee Wilhelm Steeb.

As the Hindenburg approached the landing field at Lakehurst, NJ on May 6th, 1937, Dörflein was in the crew's mess when the signal for landing stations was sounded. He went to his bunk, changed clothes, and then proceeded to his landing station in engine gondola #3. Zettel was already there, as was Steeb, the trainee. Dörflein climbed into the gondola with them, and took over on the engine throttle while Steeb observed him. Engineering officer Eugen Schäuble appeared at the doorway into the gondola shortly afterwards, but remained out on the catwalk between the engine car and the ship, observing the landing from there.


Jonny Dörflein's location at the time of the fire.


Dörflein, on orders from the control car, had given the engine one last burst at full ahead before reversing it to slow astern. Suddenly, everyone in the engine car was aware of "a shaking", and Dörflein heard "a very dull explosion" as the rear of the ship burst into flame. Schäuble shouted that the ship was on fire, and Dörflein turned around to see that the ship was ablaze above engine car #1 aft of them. Dörflein throttled down and fixed the brake on the engine as the stern of the ship dropped, with the propeller stopping just before the engine gondola hit the ground. Then Dörflein and the others leapt out and ran just before the framework of the ship collapsed all around the car.

Jonny Dörflein (circled) runs from engine car #3 as the Hindenburg collapses to the ground.



Dörflein inspects the ruins of his engine car several days after the fire.


Jonny Dörflein escaped the wreck virtually unscathed. He stayed in America long enough to testify before the Commerce Department's Board of Inquiry on May 19th, and that same day he and fellow crew survivors Egon Schweikard, Eugen Schäuble, Max Zabel, Captain Walter Ziegler and Captain Anton Wittemann made a blimp flight as guests of the United States Navy. Dörflein then returned to Germany, along with a number of his fellow crew survivors, aboard the steamship Bremen a couple of days later.

Thanks to Mary Dörflein, Jonny Dörflein's cousin, for providing me with his birth date.

Captain Anton Wittemann




Crew Member

Age: 50

Hometown: Friedrichshafen

Occupation: Captain (observer)

Location at time of fire: Control car

Survived





Captain Anton Wittemann was born in Mittelheim on March 12, 1887, and had been working on airships since 1910. Starting with the LZ 7
Deutschland, Wittemann flew on all of the DELAG ships prior to World War I, and then during the war he took part in all test and certification flights for the Zeppelins that were built for wartime service by Luftschiffbau Zeppelin. As new ships were built, Wittemann would act as a service representative for the Luftschiffbau and assist the new airships' crews as they took over their new ship. To this end, Wittemann would often fly with the new crew to their assigned base to make sure that their Zeppelin was operating in a satisfactory manner, and would then travel by train back to the airship works at Friedrichshafen-Löwenthal to begin the process with the crew for the next Zeppelin.

After the war, DELAG attempted to re-establish passenger service throughout Europe. Certified as an airship pilot in 1919, Wittemann flew aboard the LZ-120 Bodensee, which made regular flights between Friedrichshafen and Berlin between August of 1919 and July of 1921 when it, along with its newly-built sister ship, the LZ-121 Nordstern, was seized by the Inter-Allied Commission as war reparations.

When Luftschiffbau Zeppelin completed the LZ-126 for the United States Navy in 1924, Wittemann served as a navigator on the delivery flight across the Atlantic. Along with a number of other members of the German delivery crew, he then stayed in the United States for approximately three months to help to train US airshipmen in the operation of their new ship, which was officially christened Los Angeles.


Senior members of the delivery crew for the LZ-126 and US military representatives in Friedrichshafen prior to the delivery flight. From left: Lieutenant Commander Sidney M. Kraus, US Navy; Max Pruss (elevatorman); unknown; Hans Ladewig (radio operator); Hans von Schiller (navigator); Anton Wittemann (navigator); Dr. Hugo Eckener (ship's commander); Captain Hans-Curt Flemming (watch officer); Willy Speck (radio operator); Walter Scherz (helmsman); Leo Freund (radio operator); Captain George W. Steele, Jr., US Navy.
(photo courtesy of the Luftschiffbau Zeppelin GmBH Archive)


Several years later, in 1928, the Luftshiffbau built the LZ-127 Graf Zeppelin, and Wittemann once more served as a navigator. He was to make over 350 of the Graf Zeppelin's flights in all, and covered approximately a million miles in the process. On some occasions Wittemann was assigned to man the ship's elevator wheel during a particularly tricky maneuver. One such occasion arose during the Graf Zeppelin's round-the-world flight in late summer of 1929. Dr. Hugo Eckener, in command of the ship, decided to take advantage of the counterclockwise circulation of a typhoon over the Pacific Ocean to try and pick up a tail wind to help speed the ship on its way to the American coast. Wittemann, due to his experience and his considerable abilities in holding a level course, was stationed at the elevator wheel. Eckener had his helmsman approach the southern portion of the storm, chose what appeared to be the lightest spot in the massive wall of dark clouds, and ordered the ship forward into the storm.

As the intense wind currents of the typhoon suddenly and sharply pushed the ship's bow down, Wittemann compensated with the ship's elevators and brought the ship back to an even keel, holding it there as the Graf Zeppelin traversed the storm. A short while later, as the ship exited the storm, Wittemann was ready once more as an updraft pushed the ship's bow upward, and again he leveled the ship off and held it steady until they were sailing through smooth skies again. After approximately half an hour weathering the most intense storm the Graf Zeppelin had yet encountered, Dr. Eckener's instincts were proven right, and the ship had increased its speed from 50 knots to 85 knots, which lasted for another four or five hours.


Anton Wittemann takes a navigation sight aboard the Graf Zeppelin.
(photo courtesy of the Luftschiffbau Zeppelin GmBH Archive)


Anton Wittemann (left) leans out of the Graf Zeppelin's navigation room window as Captain Hans-Curt Flemming (right) passes orders to the ground crew.
(photo courtesy of the Luftschiffbau Zeppelin GmBH Archive)


By the early 1930s Anton Wittemann had been promoted to watch officer, and was eventually given command of the Graf Zeppelin on a number of flights, especially after the LZ-129 Hindenburg was put into service in 1936. At that time, a number of the Graf Zeppelin's command crew were transferred to the new ship, but Wittemann remained with the Graf Zeppelin.

Captain Wittemann was, however, aboard the Hindenburg's first North American flight of 1937 as an observer. It was his first transoceanic flight on the Hindenburg. He had originally been slated to command the Graf Zeppelin on a round-trip flight to South America beginning on April 30th, while Captain Hans von Schiller would have flown on the Hindenburg. Von Schiller, however, wanted to be back in Germany by May 11th for a 25th reunion of his old comrades from the German Naval Airship Division, and so he and Wittemann swapped places: von Schiller commanded the Graf Zeppelin down to South America, while Wittemann took his place on the Hindenburg.

Captain Ernst Lehmann, Director of Operations for the Zeppelin Company, was also aboard as an observer. During the flight, Lehmann confided to Captain Max Pruss, the ship's commander, and to Captain Wittemann that at least one warning had been received that the Hindenburg would be destroyed on this flight.

However, nothing unusual occurred during the flight other than the strong, persistent headwinds that delayed the Hindenburg's progress across the North Atlantic and put her about 12 hours behind schedule. Captain Wittemann, as an observer, had no specific duties throughout the flight, did not stand a regular watch, and instead spent much of his time familiarizing himself with the new ship and its various new systems and instruments, many of which were somewhat more advanced than those on the nine year old Graf Zeppelin.

On the final afternoon of the flight, May 6th, Wittemann climbed down into the control car when the Hindenburg was over New York. He remained there throughout the rest of the afternoon, as the ship flew over the landing field at the Lakehurst Naval Air Station at about 4:00 PM, and then continued on down the New Jersey coast to wait out some particularly bad thunderstorms that had moved into the Lakehurst area.

Finally, at 6:12 PM, word was received from Lakehurst that the weather was clearing and that the ship should come in to land. The Hindenburg began to make its way to Lakehurst about half an hour later, at 6:45, and by 7:10 the ship was making its final approach to the landing field, hovering just outside the mooring circle and dropping its bow landing lines at 7:21. Wittemann noticed, a couple minutes after the landing ropes had been dropped, that the ship was drifting off to starboard, thereby tightening the portside rope. He stood in the center of the control car watching with some concern that the landing crew might not be able to keep hold of the ship on the port side, but more importantly that the rope itself might break.


Captain Anton Wittemann's location in the control car at the time of the fire.


Suddenly Captain Wittemann heard a dull thud and felt a jolt run through the ship. He thought that the landing line had indeed broken and remarked on this. Captain Pruss replied that both ropes were fine.

Then the stern of the ship dropped as Wittemann heard somebody else in the control car shout "Fire!" Wittemann looked up and saw a bright fire above the ship, and everyone hung on as the ship tilted aft at a 45-degree angle before the bow gradually dropped back toward the ground again. As the ship descended, Wittemann noted that there was "complete quiet" in the control car.

When the control car neared the ground, Wittemann heard one of the others in the control car say "Everybody out!" As he later testified, "To my opinion, it was high time to get out too." He saw Captain Lehmann climb out through a small window toward the front of the control car's starboard side, and went to follow him. However, the top of the window frame had already begun to collapse, which slowed Wittemann's escape.

As Wittemann finished climbing through the window, he saw Captains Pruss, Lehmann, and Sammt running off to starboard. He went to follow them, but saw the burning hull crashing to the ground behind them. "There was no use for me to run into the fire, because it was clear to me that I would burn there, and that I had to look for another avenue of escape."


One of the Hindenburg's watch officers, either Anton Wittemann or Walter Ziegler, (arrow) pauses and begins to backpedal as the ship's hull collapses atop several other members of the command crew in front of him.


Wittemann therefore turned around and made his way back to the control car. He was now surrounded by burning framework and a large portion of the outer covering that had collapsed over the gondola and, along with radio officer Egon Schweikard, dropped to the ground and waited. Amazingly, he later noted that, "I was hardly bothered by the fire in that position. I did not feel any excessive heat."

Before long, Wittemann noticed that the wind was blowing the fire and smoke off to starboard, and he soon noticed a clear path out of the wreckage on the port side. He quickly got to his feet and ran to safety through "a short streak of fire that had come through." Once outside the wreckage, Wittemann waited briefly while the fire near the control car subsided, and then made his way back into the wreckage to see if anyone was still in the gondola. Satisfied that the control car was empty, Wittemann walked back out of the wreckage.

"Beyond a slight strain," Wittemann later said, "I had no injuries." He was remarkably none the worse for the wear for having been trapped under the Hindenburg's burning hull.

About two hours after the crash, Captain Wittemann sought out Commander Charles Rosendahl, commander of the Lakehurst Naval Air Station and the man in overall charge of the ground operations during the landing. He found Rosendahl talking with two FBI agents, W.S. Devereaux and E.J. Connelly, and told him that he needed to speak with him on a rather urgent matter. With the two FBI agents standing within earshot, Wittemann told Rosendahl of the warnings received before the flight. Rosendahl cautioned Wittemann to keep that particular bit of information to himself for the time being.

Wittemann spent the next two weeks in the States, and as one of the Hindenburg's ranking officers who was not confined to hospital, he worked closely with investigators, and also helped to identify bodies in the makeshift morgue that had been set up in one of the side rooms in Lakehurst's giant airship hangar. He was also, along with several other Hindenburg crew survivors, a guest on a US Navy blimp flight on May 19th.

Captain Wittemann testified before the U.S. Commerce Department's Board of Inquiry on May 20th, 1937 and, with a number of other crew survivors, sailed back to Germany a day or two later aboard the steamship Bremen. In his official testimony, he described for the Board the Hindenburg's course from the time the Hindenburg first passed over the Lakehurst air station at about 4:00 PM until the time of the crash. Also covered were the decisions made by the command crew in response to the threatening weather that passed over Lakehurst in the late afternoon, and the ensuing delay in landing.

Since Wittemann had been an observer in the control car during the landing, rather than having to focus on one specific set of tasks like the watch officers did, he was able to provide the Board a fairly comprehensive overview of the various elements of the landing maneuver: the trim of the ship on its approach to the landing field, the valving of gas and the dropping of ballast as the ship flew up to the mooring area, the various commands sent via telegraph to the engine gondolas, etc. He even answered questions from the Board about other fires aboard earlier German airships and about the precautions that had been taken against fire on the Hindenburg. He did not, however, mention the warnings about which he'd spoken with Commander Rosendahl on the night of the crash, evidently preferring to follow Rosendahl's advice and keep the matter to himself.


Captain Anton Wittemann (left) and Dr. Hugo Eckener (right) confer during the Board of Inquiry investigation.


Privately, Wittemann, like many others among the crew survivors, remained convinced that the Hindenburg had been sabotaged. Interviewed a little more than 20 years after the Hindenburg disaster, Wittemann insisted that he knew of "maybe a hundred" instances in which Zeppelins (some of which he was aboard at the time) had been struck by lightning and not once had a fire resulted. He maintained the belief that the Hindenburg had become so symbolic of the Third Reich that it invited sabotage.


Captain Wittemann stands in front of scrapped engine gondolas from both the LZ-127 Graf Zeppelin and the LZ-130 Graf Zeppelin at Frankfurt in the Spring of 1940.


Anton Wittemann retired in the Frankfurt-area town of Neu-Isenburg, where he lived until the age of 84. He passed away on December 23rd, 1971.